Showing posts with label Seasonal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Seasonal. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

2010 PUMPKIN BEER ROUNDUP

















In case you're wondering, pumpkin beer is legit.  Fruit-flavored beers don't have the best reputation, and usually for good reason.  They're often just generic ales with syrup added after the brewing process, instead of fermenting the fruit itself — frankly, some of them could pass as soda.  With the exception of lambics (a great style that bucks this trend), beer was rarely made with fruit until recently.  Yet pumpkin ale has been around for hundreds of years.  In Colonial times, American brewers couldn't afford to ship expensive ingredients overseas from England, so they used what they had around.  And what did they have?  Well, aside from apples (hard cider is perhaps the most patriotic of all beverages) they had pumpkins, the greatest of all vegetables (they are vegetables, right?)  Pumpkins, it so happens, work really well in beer, blending well with the natural bitterness of hops, and adding a unique flavor that doesn't overpower the beer or end up tasting like chemicals.  And thus the two greatest things in the world were paired, creating one of the most potentially delicious substances of all time.

GREAT:
Pumking - Southern Tier (NY)
The Great Pumpkin - Elysian  (WA)
Despite all my enthusiasm for pumpkin beer as a style, I don't think it's been perfected by most modern brewers.  Only since the mid-2000's has the style become popular, and though just about every micro has a pumpkin beer of their own now, many of them just aren't that great, or original.  Southern Tier and Elysian provide the exceptions: two wildly unique pumpkin beers with no rivals.  Despite the large number of beers on this list, no others come remotely close to these two, either in taste, style or sheer perfection.  And yet, each is completely different from the other, proving that there's more than one perfect pumpkin beer recipe — the sign of a truly worthwhile style.  I hope to see more beers compete with these two in years to come, but for now, they are without question among the best beers in the world, of any style.

GOOD:
Imperial Pumpkin Ale - Weyerbacher (PA)
Smashed Pumpkin - Shipyard (ME)
Night Owl Pumpkin - Elysian (WA)
Fisherman's Pumpkin Stout - Cape Ann Brewing Company (MA)
Punkin' Ale - Dogfish Head (DE)
A few steps down from "Great", these are still solid beers — better than many of other styles, and certainly better than most other pumpkins.  They all earn extra points for uniqueness.  Weyerbacher's entry is like a sweet brown(sugar) ale, smooth and rich with spices, simply tastier than most.  Shipyard's special, rare pumpkin (they have another, inferior entry on the list) is lighter in mouthfeel but also high in ABV, and has an interesting, earthy vegetable profile, like a chunk of raw pumpkin, somewhat similar to Night Owl, the second Elysian beer here (and nowhere near as good as their first, The Great Pumpkin). Cape Ann makes the only pumpkin stout that I've ever seen, and as you might guess, the stout taste overwhelms the pumpkin, but nonetheless makes for a very smooth, tasty beer, similar to a milk stout with a more complex profile. Dogfish Head, generally one the best breweries in America, came up with one of the first pumpkin beers in the microbrew movement.  Possibly as a result, their try is surprisingly tame for a Dogfish and not strong in pumpkin flavor — basically a brown ale with some funky caramelized flavoring.  It's nonetheless a delicious and unique beer.

AVERAGE:
Pumpkin Ale - Blue Point (NY)
Pumpkin Brewster - Sixpoint (NY)
Leaf Pile Ale - Greenport Harbor (NY)
Saranac Pumpkin Ale - The Matt Brewing Company (NY)
Pumpkin Ale - Captain Lawrence (NY)
Will Stevens' Pumpkin Ale - Wolaver's / Otter Creek (VT) 
Pumpkin Cider - Woodchuck Hard Cider (VT) 


With any style, an "average" is going to be established eventually, a standard for the style that most breweries will tend to work around.  It's already happened with pumpkin beer — a good sign for its establishment as a mainstream style, I suppose, but rather disappointing when you're trying to find something interesting to drink.  I have to assume a bit of it is laziness, as all the better pumpkin beers are rarer and pricier, whereas these beers are more easily found, often populating grocery store sixpack aisles.  The taste of this "average" is generally not strong in pumpkin flavor, and at this level, many breweries barely use any actual pumpkin in the making of their beer, resorting instead to cheap "fall" spices that give a vaguely pumpkin pie-like flavor. Blue Point and Sixpoint have new entries for 2010, and rise a bit above the rest; certainly, they're worthwhile beers to have on any occasion, even if they aren't particularly unique.  Saranac Pumpkin is a personal favorite of mine for its strong vanilla aftertaste, but once again, the pumpkin flavor is not very prominent. Woodchuck's is of course a cider, not a beer, but still deserving of placement on the list.  The pumpkin flavor is barely noticeable, adding more to the smooth, crisp mouthfeel than anything else, but it's an excellent fall drink.

SUB-PAR:
Pumpkin Barrel Ale - Fire Island (NY)
Pumpkinhead Ale - Shipyard (ME)
Pumpkin Ale - Buffalo Bill's  (CA)
Pumpkin Ale - Smuttynose (NH)
Post Road Pumpkin Ale - Brooklyn Brewery (NY)
Smiling Pumpkin - Heartland Brewery (NY)
Compared to the entire world of beer out there, none of these are exactly bad beers.  If you see one in a bar and don't have many other options, by all means, give it a try.  But Smuttynose and Brooklyn Brewery unfairly hog grocery store aisles with their sixpacks, crowding out many superior pumpkin beers that just didn't land widespread distribution deals — and that annoys me.  Most of these are very similar to the "standard pumpkin beer recipe" I talked about above, but with a few tweaks that bring out the more unpleasant characteristics of the beer.  If you like bitter, sharper beers (but not as a result of hops, which are barely noticeable) then this may simply be a difference of opinion.  I find the mouthfeel watery and unpleasant and the pumpkin taste almost gimmicky.  Still.  Could be worse.

AVOID:
Harvest Moon Pumpkin Ale - Coors (CO)
Jack's Pumpkin Spice Ale - Anheuser-Busch (MO)
"Worse."  Avoid.  Don't ask questions.  Just walk away.

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

SUMMER: BEST TIME OF YEAR TO GO FOLK YOURSELF

















I enjoy making mixtapes. Who doesn't?  I like all kinds of mixtapes: mixtapes with subliminal messages, mixtapes as birthday presents, mixtapes for new friends, mixtapes that strongly urge you to consider settling this out of court, mixtapes with codes that will lead to hidden treasure, and mixtapes that are actually just Led Zeppelin III.  I also quite frequently associate certain albums and songs with seasons of the year, so I like making mixtapes with that in mind too.  A few years ago, while totally high on boredom and Lucky Charms cereal, I decided to undertake the ambitious project of making mixes for all four seasons of the year.  It was fun, and highlighted a very specific way that I listen to music, but I soon realized that it was not something I could continue to do. I simply don't have enough season-specific music to make a new, original mix every year.  So now, three years and a couple hundred albums later, I'm back at it — but this time, I'm only doing one a year, moving a season ahead every year.  In other words, "summer" in 2010, "fall" in 2011, "winter" the year after that, and so on. 

"What," you may ask, "makes certain music feel like summer?"  I suppose that's highly dependent on each individual person's taste, as well as their feelings toward summer, but I think most would agree that summer music is ideally fun and upbeat.  I would add that it's a bit edgier than spring, maybe even a little wistful, with a sense of urgency, yet not as melancholy as fall.  It should feel warm, yet not overly-superficial or sterile.  "Also," you may now point out, "You sound like a pretentious hipster douchebag.  Wistful? Urgency? You're such a dick."

You know what I have to say to that?

SUMMER: BEST TIME OF YEAR TO GO FOLK YOURSELF
1. Settler (by) Balmorhea
2. Come Talk To Me (by) Bon Iver
3. Write It All Down For You (by) Elliott Brood 
4. Sideswiper (by) Fang Island
5. Some Are White Light (by) Caspian
6. Catch Hell Blues (by) The White Stripes
7. Bron-Y Aur Stomp (by) Led Zeppelin
8. Liner (by) Justin Vernon
9. The Gnashing (by) Baroness
10. Aves (by) Gifts From Enola
11. Þau Hafa Sloppið Undan Þunga Myrkursins (by) Ólafur Arnalds

Many would likely make a summer playlist of super-dancey pop tunes, and while I wanted to go for a warmer, more simplistic feel, I didn't want to get far away from that frivolous summer energy.  This year I've been discovering a lot of folk music, a genre which I had always under-appreciated, and it turns out that a lot of it is pretty good for conveying the warmth and earnestness I associate with summer. Balmorhea opens the mix with a Westerny twist on chamber music, spinning together handclaps, happy gang-vocals and what basically amounts to a neo-classical hoedown into one of the best songs I've ever heard, and one that would put me in a good mood even if a doctor were simultaneously telling me that I'd just been diagnosed with leprosy.  Bon Iver then proves how godlike he is by turning a Peter Gabriel song into a stupidly catchy, slow-burning folk tune full of remorse and longing, and making it fun at the same time.  Elliott Brood kicks it up a notch with their self-styled "Death Country," and Fang Island then proceeds to shred some nasty riffs all over your face.  For an instrumental interlude, Caspian demonstrates how heavy and thick a song can go while still retaining atmosphere and beauty, slipping some pedal steel guitar all up in there, just in time before Jack White leads us to hot water with one of the nastiest, beastly riffs I've ever heard.  Seriously, the slide guitar in "Catch Hell Blues" should have its own theme park ride.  If Led Zeppelin's entry doesn't have your foot stomping, well, I'm sorry about your amputation, but I hear prosthetic limbs are getting better all the time.  Justin Vernon takes it down a notch for some introspection before Baroness bounces right back with a rollicking, unstoppable monster from their recent Blue Record, one of my favorite summer albums.  Gifts From Enola's entry is paced quite differently than most, and nearly twice as long as any other song on here, but hang in there: last year's From Fathoms is also a perfect summer album, and this closer tosses more killer riffs in your direction than everything else on the mix combined before cooling things off a bit.  Finally, with summer ending, Iceland's Ólafur Arnalds combines a sense of optimism, nostalgia and wistfulness in a stunningly emotional, neo-classical epilogue.

Sunday, March 14, 2010

THE FIRE IN OUR THROATS WILL BECKON THE THAW (BY) PELICAN

Post-Metal / Sludge / Atmospheric
Released 2005

I was recently having a discussion with some peers about which albums most influenced our lives — albums that have not only stuck with us, but after first discovering them, drastically affected what music we listen to and how we listen to it.  I can pinpoint many albums that were, in retrospect, important to my current tastes, but most of them were simple progressions of things I was already listening to, another evolutionary link.  Other albums got me into new habits — my flirtations with metal were spread out over multiple years and many extremely different albums — but didn't themselves make a lasting impression, and in retrospect only presented a few easily-digested morsels that encouraged me to pursue new things, new tastes.

When a friend introduced me to The Fire In Our Throats Will Beckon the Thaw in the spring of my junior year of college, the timing couldn't have been more perfect.  For a few months, I had been seeking out experimental, heavy music. I already had a hunch then that I would never be a real metal-head, but I liked a lot of the things metal bands were doing, even if I was having a hard time getting past the often-difficult vocals.  Though I'd been occasionally listening to Godspeed You! Black Emperor since high school, I didn't really have awareness of instrumental music at that point.  GY!BE still seemed to me like a soundtrack lacking a movie, and like most people, I didn't understand why a band would decide to remain instrumental.  So Pelican came out of nowhere — I had truly never heard anything like it before.

Now, kids these days can easily describe entire subgenres of instrumental metal by the degree to which they rip off of Pelican (and other forebears of the post-metal movement), but hearing such a thing for the first time, or describing it to someone else, is like trying to explain to a blind man what "green" looks like.  I remember once telling my father that Pelican reminded me of Pink Floyd — a comparison that's so laughably erroneous four years later, I haven't the slightest idea what I might I have been referring to.  The Fire In Our Throats is, for lack of a better word, glacial — not usually a word I'd use to describe music, but I can't think of anything else that fits so well.  It's cold and stark and huge, slow-moving and dense, but most importantly, it's a glacier in retreat, one leaving behind a vision of spring and growth and possibility.  There's a deep-rooted, earthy sense of beauty in Pelican's music, little touches of warmth and grace amidst all the thundering walls of riffage and distortion, not to mention their extremely unique, perfect executed acoustic transitions.  Amidst the calamity, The Fire In Our Throats evokes the sense that one has finally reached The Last Day of Winter (and whatdayaknow, that's the name of the first song!)  Within such an unsubtle musical style, it's an unexpected touch of subtlety that other bands trying to bogart Pelican's thunderous tone seem to completely miss.  A wall of sound becomes boring eventually — we want to be led somewhere, and sludge-metal is at best a way to move us.  Where many other post-rockers tend to paint a scene that's other-worldly, or post-worldly, The Fire In Our Throats is intensely familiar.  Rather than nostalgia, it evokes a sense of expectation.  It somehow makes the air around you feel fucking crisp.  If you listen to it in winter, you will feel striking disappointment when you step outside and see a gray, snow-filled sky.  Studies show playing it once a day will cause plants to grow 34% faster.  (It's science!)

One particular memory perfectly captures all the feelings that Pelican still evokes in me.  As I said before, the timing of my discovery couldn't have been more perfect.  It was spring.  Metal is generally considered depressive stuff, but Pelican is anything but.  That winter had been a particularly difficult time of my life, and it's no exaggeration to say that I felt totally buried in frustrations and anxieties.  Timid music wasn't going to do anything to move me, but The Fire In Our Throats is as uplifting and inspiring as it is loud.  Like spring, there's a sense that mounds of filth are being washed away — forcefully, cathartically, and jarringly.  I needed that, then, and so I took a walk on the first day of spring, past all the sun-tanning sorority girls and shirtless jock douchemonkeys, and went down to the Hudson.  It felt good to get off campus and out of sight.  I found a spot above a cliff and watched car-sized chunks of ice floating down the river, I stared at the mountains that surrounded me, and I realized just how fucking much I loved the Hudson River Valley — everything except that small vortex of suck that was Poughkeepsie.  I could feel the cold whenever the breeze picked up, but it was still warm enough to wear a t-shirt.  And somehow, Pelican was playing exactly what I was feeling and seeing — without words.  I had never experienced that from music before. Suddenly I was getting punched in the face by a sort of frontiersman's spirit, awed by the severity of nature and music with the ability to capture it as textures and sounds.  I felt, dare I say, inspired.

So, Pelican got me into instrumental music, heavy music, and oddly enough, hiking.  (Cool story, bro).  The sense of gravitas and yearning their music evokes has never worn off, and I always feel an urge to put it on when I venture out to Upstate New York.  Sadly, their last two releases have been solidly mediocre, and their sound has since been regurgitated by dozens of bands, bottled and packaged as a tepid subgenre.  It's obvious in retrospect that Pelican's strengths also demand a rather inflexible formula, and after creating such a perfectly-executed landmark album, they'd basically written themselves into a corner.  (I should note that their first album, Australasia, is nearly on par with The Fire In Our Throats, yet presents a markedly different atmosphere).  The Fire In Our Throats still stands as one of the most evocative and emotional albums in my collection, a testament to the (seldom-realized) fact that beautiful music doesn't have to be timid or cloying.

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

THE MANTLE (BY) AGALLOCH

Neofolk / Metal / Progressive / Soundscape
Released 2002

[For an explanation of Season Albums and Pivotal Albums, please go here.]

Agalloch is one of those bands that, if I bothered to organize and write out my Top 50 Albums of All Time, would so easily dominate the top of the list that the effort would seem to be pointless in the end.  They'd have two albums in the Top 10 and an EP in the Top 15 — it just wouldn't seem fair, though it would reflect how important (pivotal, if you will) their music has become to me. Agalloch is one of those bands — and I hope everyone has at least a few of their own — that is so perfectly tapped into what I desire and enjoy in music that their albums are literally flawless to me, every element so shockingly interesting and engaging with every listen that, no matter how many times I've heard it before, each time I'm surprised to find just how much I like them.

Despite forming over a decade ago, Agalloch's blend of dark atmospheric folk, post-rock soundscapes and black metal gravitas has proven too intricate and complex to spawn any successful imitators.  Those who try seem to capture no more than one or two elements of Agalloch's sound, dividing it up until the result is meaningless, or silly.  On paper, Agalloch doesn't seem all that far removed from the many gimmicky "folk metal" bands out there, but Agalloch isn't interested in simply re-appropriating some traditional musical style — despite my usage of the genre term "folk."  What they're playing sounds folky, but the actual elements are not stolen specifically from anywhere.  There are some unique pieces of instrumentation, sure, but you almost don't notice them, and they're certainly not the focus.  In "The Lodge", for instance, Agalloch creates a surreal echo by striking a deer skull — but you would never realize what you were hearing unless you read it somewhere.  Other songs feature the deep, creepy menace of a cello, or sound clips of footsteps crunching snow, but the songs are driven by simple, standard instrumentation, written in such a way as to evoke a cold winter landscape and carried to perfection by the harsh, dual-vocals and lyrical paganism.

Perhaps the problem of capturing Agalloch's success (or even getting Pandora to recommend anything remotely similar) lies in the term "folk".  Not only has it been around forever (literally), it's currently one of the most re-interpreted and re-imagined genres out there, other than metal.  There's a reason why folk music is forced to embrace every bearded, flannel wearing dude who just wants to strum his acoustic and recite poetry in a breathy voice — well, other than the fact that "I want to have sex with the largest possible number of girls with the least amount of effort" is too long to catch on as a genre term.  Folk has always been around because it is traditional music, which is by necessity always in flux, played by "the people," so to speak.  Traditional instruments can be a part of it, but "folk" literally means "people," and thus singer-songwriters are always sort-of folk regardless of their actual musical orientation.  Thus, for all its vagueyness and ability to transform into confusing other things, folk is a terrible term when you're trying to denote an incredibly specific sound — as anyone who wishes to describe Agalloch's music certainly is.  I'd argue that there should, in fact, be an invented genre term so bands who actually evoke the feeling of being in nature can distinguish themselves — I've heard the term "soundscape" used before, though seldomly, and I'd argue that it's a far more accurate indicator than just another "folk" subbranch with a silly name.

Since this is not a review, I'm not going to spend much time analyzing the actual music of The Mantle.  It's complex in a shifting, understated way, though deceptively straightforward in execution, and as is the case with pretty much every band I editorialize on here, I feel like I would spend the majority of my words just defending the fact that cross-genre hybrids can work without feeling cluttered and disjointed.  There's a clear trend in what I enjoy: textured, layered music that doesn't just borrow from one genre, and even after combining its elements together into a coherent sound, doesn't fit easily into another.  Songs on The Mantle are long and patiently crafted, unhurried and expansive, pagan, cold, eerie; they make you feel like you're stranded in a lodge in the middle of the woods, in winter. The vocals — the most metal aspect of the band — are likely difficult for new listeners, but match the cold textures and dynamics of Agalloch's songwriting, both harsh and clean vocals soon blending into the layered sounds surrounding them.  If you listen to The Mantle in summer, it will still sound like winter (Agalloch has another album for summer).  If you listen to it driving through the Catskills in a fancy SUV, you will still feel desolate and trapped and cold.  Though it's never particularly heavy, fast-paced or intimidating in the way that most metal is, this is a brutal album as much as it is a beautiful album.  The Mantle isn't made to be played at festivals or Burning Man; it isn't a commentary on the fastidiousness or overproduction of modern music; it isn't a reproduction of the bloody good old days of European battle-songs and beer-filled taverns; it has nothing at all to do with people — it is the outdoors, and the influence is inescapable.

Saturday, February 6, 2010

PIVOTAL ALBUMS & SEASONAL MUSIC: AN EXPLANATION

In an effort to give myself the opportunity to write about music more often, I'm "launching" a new "feature" on The Luxury Yacht Review.  I never review new albums outright on here, for a variety of reasons that I won't get into, but I would like to discuss music, as it's of equal importance as books to me — and so, I will post editorials instead of reviews, focusing on pivotal albums in my collection, albums that are significant with regards to how I listen to music.  The first of these two overlapping features, Seasonal Albums, is meant to discuss albums that highlight how I listen to music.  Certain albums, regardless of when I discovered them, create extremely vivid soundscapes for me, transporting me to a time or place or often conjuring a whole season.  Many albums with this power have greatly affected my mindset and preferences for music, and their evocative power makes them far more than just "entertainment" to me.

These seasonal albums will, for obvious reasons, often overlap with my second, also loosely structured feature — a sort of unranked Top 50 Albums of All Time deal, generalized here as Pivotal Albums.  Instead of actually making such a list and stressing about its order, by posting editorials at random, I can feature albums that likely would place without having to pit them against one another.  These albums will provide a window into my constantly-shifting musical tastes, as they are the albums which have determined that taste and then weathered my peculiar, inscrutable whims.  They may yet fall or rise in my favor with time, but these are the albums which will continue to influence me until I turn into a crotchety old man who only listens to Led Zeppelin while sitting on his porch drinking beer.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

ADIRONDACK MOUNTAIN CABIN; ZOMBIE FLIES


The weather certainly hates me this fall, but until I figure out which rain gods I'm meant to be sacrificing to, I just try to get hiking or camping or outdoors-at-all at any possible opportunity. Jim, Ali and I have been talking about going to Jim's family house in the Adirondack mountains ever since he moved up here. Thanks to Life, it never happened... until now.

I figured the end of October would be perfect, with the leaves turning and the fall chill settling in for good. The foliage was indeed incredible, and there was plenty of it to see. Unfortunately, it seems to rain any time I might possibly step outdoors, and to my incredible frustration the forecast for this weekend was dismal—but the plans were made, and we weren't likely to get any hiking done if we waited until December and it was all that much colder. At the very, very last minute, Jim's parents also helpfully informed us that it was the first weekend of hunting season, and since we weren't going to be hiking in an actual state park, we were likely to get shot and possibly sodomized should we venture outside. High fives were exchanged in the general spirit of awesomeness.

After enjoying a Young's Double Chocolate Stout on the lovely train ride to Poughkeepsie, Ali and I marched to the newly-opened Hudson River Walkway while awaiting Jim's arrival. It was a bit of a hike to get there, but the Walkway is impressive enough to warrant it—incredibly impressive, actually, considering what I've come to expect from Poughkeepsie. If you've ever been to that asshole of a town, you've seen the train bridge lurking over the Hudson, a huge, strange, slightly-tragic marvel of 1800's engineering. It always looked like a ruin, obviously abandoned at a glance, and so mammoth that it seemed it would bring the whole town down with it, should it ever fall. Turning it into a public park, similar to the Highline in Manhattan, was a brilliant idea. The bridge seems no less vast from atop the modern, unadventurous concrete walkway that now spans it—in fact, it seems all the larger, as you have to walk a good fifteen minutes before you're even over the Hudson itself, and from there the bridge still spans so wide you can't tell what awaits at the other side. Unfortunately, I cannot personally vouch for that discovery, as the sky unleashed its wrath just as we began our trek across the Hudson, forcing us to turn back. It was a cruel torment, but we were starved and thirsty and not in possession of any rain gear, so we resolved to return in less hostile conditions and explore the bridge to its fullest.

A series of revisitations followed from there—Noah's, only to find that Honey Brown is sadly no longer on tap and that Marist students have only become douchier and more bro-tastic; Half Time, my old paramour; and Terrapin, that haven of upscale dining in isolated Rhinebeck. I learned that duck, when applied to a sandwich and bathed in BBQ sauce, is much like pulled-pork, and should never be eaten on a date. That shit is greasy like a Staten Island resident. Eventually, on that rainy eve, our frivolous little trio reached Jimmy's Mountain House in the Adirondacks.

Thursday, October 15, 2009

2009 FALL BEER REVIEW

With the style's surging popularity in recent years, it seems almost every micro is now trying their hand at a pumpkin ale. Unlike other "fruit/vegetable" beers, pumpkin beers aren't as much of a gimmick, as the style was common in Colonial times (other beer ingredients, which had to be shipped to the colonies, were more expensive than native pumpkins). Many American breweries often treat "fruit" beers as a trick to entice non-beer-drinkers, and the results rarely hold up. This is still the case with many pumpkin beers, but there are those brave few prepared to craft this fine style as it deserves, demonstrating yet again why beer is the only drink befitting a Civilized Man.

Harvest Moon Pumpkin Ale - Coors Brewing Co. (CO)
Jack's Pumpkin Spice Ale - Anheuser-Busch (MO)
VERDICT: No
Danger, Will Robinson!

Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale - Smuttynose Brewing Company (NH)
Post Road Pumpkin Ale - Brooklyn Brewery
(NY)
Pumpkinhead Ale - Shipyard Brewing Co. (ME)
Buffalo Bill's Pumpkin Ale - Buffalo Bill's Brewery (CA)
VERDICT: Meh; meh; meh; meh
All bland, generic ales with some vaguely autumnal spices thrown in. These are otherwise great breweries, and I'm really disappointed how little effort they seemed to put into these seasonal beers.  I do not believe any use actual pumpkin in the brewing process, so they're kind of gimmicks, but yet they're some of the most common found in grocery stores during autumn.  Too bitter or too watery, too bland, barely any pumpkin taste. There are worse beers out there, and these remain (mostly) drinkable, but they give the concept of pumpkin beer a bad face for the general public.

Saranac Pumpkin Ale - The Matt Brewing Company (NY)
VERDICT: Drinkable
Saranac usually makes very fine beers, in my experience — not daring, unique or mindblowing, but consistent, reliable and drinkable. Saranac Pumpkin is unsurprisingly the best of the commonly available six pack pumpkins, and cheap too. The pumpkin taste comes in clear here, and right up-front. There are slight bitter notes, but nothing odd, and the aftertaste is of a pleasant, smooth vanilla that remains until the taste is gone altogether. You can savor this beer or guzzle it, and it works either way. Granted, the pumpkin flavor is never strong, and as it's upfront, it's not wholly memorable or lingering. As the beer sits and you reach the bottom of the bottle, the vanilla becomes far more prominent, all but drowning out the spices. Still, given its price and taste, this is one of the best session pumpkin beers.

Pumpkin Ale - Captain Lawrence (NY)
VERDICT: Good
The Cap'n's pumpkin attempt isn't really the most anything, but it's a bit smoother and richer than the Saranac, and holds its flavor well throughout. The pumpkin taste is never strong, and though you get a bit of that usual bitter-spiciness up front, the overall mouthfeel is very sweet without any exact source that stands out — for good or bad. The taste levels quickly, and the smoothness of this ale means quite a lot of it can go down quickly. Still, for a brewery like this, and a beer that's not even available in bottles, I would have expected and enjoyed a much stronger, bolder flavor.

Will Stevens' Pumpkin Ale - Wolaver's / Otter Creek Brewing (VT)
VERDICT: Decent
Similar to the Captain Lawrence entry, this exuberantly-titled pumpkin is actually fairly plain. A smooth, medium-body ale, this one isn't too spicy, and the pumpkin flavor was subtle but enjoyable. There's also a pleasant lack of bitterness, and the flavoring and mouthfeel are consistent, so it has that going for it. Nothing remarkable, but not bad, so I won't argue with another pumpkin beer to choose from.

Fisherman's Pumpkin Stout - Cape Ann Brewing Company (MA)
VERDICT: Good, though surprisingly unremarkable
Well, this is different. A pumpkin stout. It looks like a stout, certainly the darkest I've seen any pumpkin beer. It mostly tastes like a stout, too, but I wasn't expecting the most pumpkiny thing since the Charlie Brown Halloween Special, either. The pumpkin surges through the mouth as a sort of overtone, never really feeling present but nonetheless adding a tasty character to the beer. Well balanced. This is fairly creamy and smooth as stouts go, definitely an easy-drinker. You miss out on the spicy-sweet flavors that make other good pumpkin beers appealing, but the combo of slightly-bitter pumpkin flavoring and a rich stout mouthfeel go surprisingly well together. The aftertaste is almost sweet. I wouldn't say this is notable as a pumpkin beer, and probably wouldn't appeal to stout-snobs, but for a fan of both styles with an open mind, this is actually a quite solid entry.

Punkin' Ale - Dogfish Head (DE)
VERDICT: Slightly misleading, but good
Dogfish Head is reliable as always, though with so much competition in this area, not as innovate as with their other offerings. Their Punkin Ale is a rich brown ale, somewhat darker and richer than many other pumpkins. Instead of strong spices or strong pumpkin flavor, they've gone with more of a caramelized brown sugary taste and heavy malts. The pumpkin comes in, but thoroughly blended with all the other flavors, which are hard to tell apart. Very drinkable, and the flavors never become unpleasant, despite the richness.

Night Owl Pumpkin - Elysian Brewing Company (WA)
VERDICT: Debatable
I would wager that few micros have created so many varieties of pumpkin beer as Elysian — a holyshit six, maybe more. Night Owl is a solid entry, though still reliant on spices more than pumpkin, which hits mostly in the aftertaste. The wallop of spices isn't unpleasant, but overall I am reminded of poorly-baked pumpkin bread rather than well-spiced pumpkin pie. I would recommend this on taste, but given the price and quantity (8 dollars for a 22 ounce bottle) there are almost certainly going to be better options.

The Great Pumpkin - Elysian Brewing Company (WA)
VERDICT: Perfect
Now we're getting to what pumpkin beer should be. This would rank in my Top 10 of beers alone, and is the second best pumpkin beer I've had — possibly tied for first depending on my mood. I had this at Blind Tiger in the West Village, so I can't vouch for availability in bottles, but its 7 dollar per-glass price point conveniently discouraged me from sitting there and literally bathing myself in this holy nectar all night, as I otherwise would have done. The pumpkin taste here is strong, finally resembling a thick creamy slice of pumpkin pie, but what made this notable for me is the even leveling of the spices, which never became overwhelming and fade nicely in the aftertaste. This is an incredibly consistent beer. The mouthfeel is neither thin nor overly rich, which makes it go down all-the-more easily. Even at 8% ABV, this beer is dangerously drinkable, and puts Elysian on my list of breweries to keep track of. Delicious.

Pumking Ale - Southern Tier Brewing Company (NY)
VERDICT: Perfect
I really can't say a lot about this beer, it's just... good.  I mean: amazing.  9% ABV that you'll never notice. Insane pumpkin-pie mouthfeel. Thick and rewarding but not syrupy, satisfying from initial onset to the last note, never once timid. Pleasant, lingering aftertaste. What sets this apart from The Great Pumpkin is the complex, shifting pallet of flavors — enough to keep you guessing until the 22 ounce bottle is gone, whereas the former retains a very consistent flavor from beginning to end, top to bottom. This is a daring, adventurous beer, and highly rewarding. When you open Pumking, choirs of angels surge forth from the heavens. Scantily clad women throw themselves upon you because of your remarkable good taste. Probably, at this moment, my all-time favorite beer.  So please don't drink it.  It's only available for about a month of the year, and I want it all.

Related Posts-