Showing posts with label Good. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Good. Show all posts

Monday, April 25, 2011

THE RUNNING MAN (BY) STEPHEN KING

Published 1982, 336 pages
Characters: B
Writing: B-
Plot: B+
Pacing: B+
Poignancy: B

It's not terribly important that I decided to pick up the Running Man because I read countless discussions online pointing out its similarity to the currently-popular Hunger Games trilogy, which I read in March. But out of the dozens of novels Stephen King has written — which I will probably never entirely catch up on — that's why I decided to pick up this one just now.

Though nearly three decades separate the publication of the novels, the similarities are pretty glaring. The Hunger Games is an almost perfect synthesis of The Running Man and Battle Royale. Stephen King's 1982 novel is only set in 2025, and as with the best, most convincing near-future sci-fi, not much is all the different — everything is just a bit shittier. The people tune in to a series of increasingly dangerous reality-TV show contests for amusement, run by a sinister government entertainment Network. A man named Richards, desperate for money to save his diseased young daughter, enters into the most dangerous and popular reality program in the country: The Running Man. It's pretty much what it sounds like, a nationwide manhunt which nearly everyone watches, and in which anyone can participate. If Richards manages to survive for 30 days, he's set for life, rich beyond meaning. In the history of the game, no one has ever survived more than 8 days.

So you have the evil corrupt government, the death-game, the reality-TV angle being used to control and manipulate the masses. The main reason I bring up these comparisons is because The Hunger Games utilized that reality-TV angle so poorly, when it was clearly a goldmine idea with a lot of potential. It was never clear who watched or who cared or what significance any of it might have in the world at large. King clears that problem here, making it all feel tangible and believable, with plenty of first-hand demonstration on what effect this reality-TV population control has, and why people in a society like ours might even buy into it. He does this while breezing through the action of the novel, too, integrating exposition with pacing and plot development. It's impressive, and only the beginning of the novel suffers for it, with the first few beats of the story seeming a little rushed and jarring.

The world is convincing, and the story is tight. There's really not much beyond that — like The Hunger Games, this is a lean book and a fast read. (I read nearly the entire thing on a four hour bus ride back to Lebanon.) It's appropriately gritty and uncompromising, and Richards makes for a sympathetic, jaded, smug, noir-ish narrator. I should note that The Running Man was written under King's long-defunct Richard Bachman pen-name, and thus there are some interesting and fitting stylistic differences from King's usual stuff. The prose is much leaner and harder, less folksy and rambling than typical. Richard the character fits Richard the pen-name, and everything fits this grim but sardonic world.

One last thing: that Arnold Schwarzenegger film of the same name is, in fact, based off of this book. I have never seen it. I doubt it's very similar but I'm curious to check it out. King doesn't pull any punches with the ending, and without changing that part around significantly, this is one story I can guarantee that Hollywood will never be tempted to remake.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

SUBURBAN DISCONTENT: AMERICAN BEAUTY AND REVOLUTIONARY ROAD



Until I sat down to write this review, it hadn't actually occurred to me that Sam Mendes directed both American Beauty (1999) and Revolutionary Road (2008).  I remembered that he was responsible for at least one of them, but I figured I was getting myself confused and couldn't remember which.  So that wasn't why I decided to write this joint analysis — honestly, I just happened to watch both films within a week of each other, and I was struck by how well they complimented each other thematically.  And now... that makes sense.  Both are films book-ending the era of American suburban expansion, examining jaded, former idealists — and taken together, they add up to a unique statement on American suburban ennui.  I wonder where Sam Mendes lives?

I already agree with the angle Mendes seems to be honing in on, but I suspect it isn't terribly important to what's going on here.  These films aren't about the suburbs being good or bad on their own.  They never attempt to demonstrate that suburbs are culturally bankrupt compared to other modes of living, or inferior to cities, even if their inhabitants are shown in a harsh light  These aren't films about societal sustainability — they're about cultural sustainability.  Mendes falls upon the suburbs as a symbol of a lifestyle that was becoming quintessentially American around the time of Revolutionary Road, and by American Beauty's era, had established itself as the status quo.  In another sense, the suburbs are simply a metaphor for failed American idealism.

Back before I realized that both had the same director, I was especially struck by how much these movies are inversions of each other.  Revolutionary Road is set in Connecticut in the 50's, and follows a couple (Kate Winslet and Leonardo DiCaprio) forced to settle down because of their kids.  They are a pair of vaguely-artistic self-appointed outsiders; they consider themselves better than the system, and want to move to Paris to regroup and figure out what their calling in life is. Friends of the couple consider them immature and slightly crazy for wanting to pack up and leave — like many idealists, DiCaprio's character seems to have no idea what he's running to or what he's running from, and that's where the trouble appears.  After all, 50's America was a time of finally embracing normalcy, when suburban societal rhythms were being established and America as a whole was transforming into a middle aged version of itself, rich and ready to pay for reliable comforts and picket fences.  On its own, Revolutionary Road is a fascinating look at the underside of an era when media, advertising and government were bizarrely united in portraying a simplified, sterilized image of regular American life.  "Normalcy does not inspire happiness" could be the tagline of either of these films.  American Beauty takes place presumably at the same time it was filmed, the late nineties, and once again develops around a married couple who appear normal, who try to act happy, and are neither of those things.  It's another story of a marriage falling apart, another warning that one day you might wake up and out-of-nowhere realize how miserable you are. Both stories spiral toward tragedy due to miscommunication and discontent — or maybe inevitability.  On the surface, these films would seem to more or less make the same statement, but it's the differences in tone that captured my interest — like I said, they serve as book-ends, not only to the way culture changed (or didn't change) in the five decades between their characters, but also in the decade separating their creation.   

American Beauty is very much a 90's movie, both in its setting and feel — flippant, jaded, sarcastic.  Everything is slightly tongue-and-cheek, yet with that undercurrent of anti-corporate, anti-establishment cynicism that cropped up after the Reagan era but never congealed with the focus of the 70's punk era.  It's no fluke here, and the cynicism may not all trace back to Mendes.  While rewatching Beauty, I was struck how close in tone it is to another movie from the same period: Donnie Darko.  These movies wouldn't seem to have anything in common on the surface, but if you strip out the metaphysical sci-fi from Darko, the rest is strikingly similar in tone and ideology.  It's the era, not specific filmmakers, of course. That cynical, middle-finger sense of humor can be found in other 90's movies like Office Space, Clerks, Fight Club, and so on.  A lot of the material in American Beauty could have been even darker than it was, if not centered around such a relaxed, enjoyable actor as Kevin Spacey.  Yet compared to Revolutionary Road, Beauty seems tame, almost a comedy.  There are fewer sinister events in Revolutionary Road, up until its ending, yet the film feels much colder. It lacks humor; its characters seem doomed — there's an almost apocalyptic air to it, as if innocent young America were ambling along obliviously into decades of chaos and war (well, okay.)  That the story is so simple, the character's struggles so domestic, only makes it seem more tragic.  Decades later, America had suffered plenty, and suddenly the same suburban discontent is skewed from the other end.  The same unanswerable questions about marriage and happiness and success — suddenly it's not that you're looking ahead and seeing dark clouds on the horizon, you're looking back, thinking, "Oh, whatever. That sucked.  F**k it."  It's a perspective uniting both the cultural background of the movies, and the characters themselves: in Revolutionary Road, the couple is young, eager, looking forward to life; in Beauty, they've endured a thankless marriage for years, and are bored with their suffering.  Even their young daughter has already become resigned, ready to run off with a boy who shows some hint of unconformity and passion.

It's probably suggestive that the dread Road builds around was best captured in the 00's, despite it serving as a period piece.  The mood is straightforward, haunted, capturing the feeling that something big has changed and god knows what those changes might mean.  The suburban lifestyle was well established by the 90's, but that feeling of despair over mere angst has reappeared in strength these last few years.  Except this time, it isn't a sense of naive idealism that's failing us — it's the ability to survive through apathy and sarcasm.  And not in a good way.  We found no relief in the 00's, in the honest, unadorned tone of films like Revolutionary Road.  By the end of the movie, the characters don't really know how to react — they simply are where they are, and there's little they can do about it until their lives return to something that appears normal.

Friday, January 7, 2011

BLACK SWAN (2010, DARREN ARANOFSKY)



Black Swan makes a pretty good first film to review, it turns out. It's a really well made movie, objectively, yet I didn't particularly enjoy the experience of watching it.  Movies like this contain some interesting lessons in the subjectivity inherent to enjoyment of films, something that film criticism often ignores entirely. Black Swan is a psychological horror movie, and probably the most painfully tense movie I've seen since No Country For Old Men. Don't watch the trailer (more on that later.)  All you need to know, plot-wise, is that this is a heavily tone and character based movie about a ballerina losing herself to the music, the moment. (This opportunity comes once in a lifetime, yo.)  It will be enjoyed by those who enjoy horror, and it deserves to earn Oscar noms for Aranofsky and Natalie Portman. It's an impressive and interesting movie, certainly.  But if you, like me, have never learned to savor horror-tinged tension, cringe-worthy scenes of fingernail clipping, body mutilation and creaking, bloody feet, all enacted by off-putting, obsessive characters, there's very little else here to enjoy. (And, Jesus spinning Christ, I never want to see anyone's foot ever again.)

On a technical level, the movie is nearly impeccable.  Aranofsky's direction embodies both the technical perfection and unhinged madness discussed throughout the movie, even if he tries maybe a bit too hard, getting a little overblown toward the end and tossing out too much over-thought cinematography, such as Vincent Cassel's absurdly black-and-white apartment full of swan imagery.  Portman is perhaps the best thing about the movie, and shapes her character effortlessly.

I mentioned not to watch the trailer. Don't. If you know anything about the movie at all, there are few surprises here. Really, that was my greatest disappointment: everything happened exactly as I expected it to.  The story does hold a few surprises in the end, but only in the specifics — I assumed it would have a certain 'type' of ending, and it did. Aside from cringing at the many uncomfortable scenes, I felt like I was watching a movie I had seen a few years ago and forgotten about. It's not that the trailer gives anything away; it's more that there isn't much to give away, once you get a handle on the characters and style of the film. Of course, the storytelling in Black Swan is far from lazy; it's just based on the assumption that you enjoy tension. Granted, I've enjoyed many other tension-filled movies, but most of them have some form of payoff. No Country For Old Men was almost unbearable to watch, but I'd say I enjoyed the film because of its unique characters and mixture of Western and Noir tones, the message that tension was sculpting.  And that is, of course, boiling things down to my personal taste.  Black Swan is a very dry movie.  If you like the tone here, then you'll like the movie. If you don't — well, there's little else going on except the impressive direction and acting. There isn't a single moment of comedy, nor are there really any character or societal insights. It's fine for a movie to be so singularly focused. It's why film criticism so often misses the point. Black Swan isn't trying to appeal to everyone. (It might be trying a little too hard to appeal to the Oscar crowd, but I digress.)  As a very well-made, artistically accomplished film, it has nothing else to prove; it does what it does quite well.

Grade: B

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

THE LAST AMERICAN MAN (BY) ELIZABETH GILBERT

Published 2002, 268 pages
Characters: n/a
Writing: B
Plot: B+
Pacing: B+
Poignancy: B+

It's rare to find a biography as thorough and intimate as The Last American Man.  Of course, there aren't many subjects out there like Eustace Conway.  Since a very young age, Conway has taught and lived self-sufficient living, but he's more than just a naturalist and mountain-man.  He's a man that can conquer seemingly any goal he sets for himself, a man that seems to have nearly superhuman physical powers, and a mind to match.  At the age of seventeen, Conway left his parent's suburban home, built a tee-pee in the wilderness, made all his clothing out of deer-skin, and has more or less lived like that ever since.  Conway's is a complex story that could have easily been told through a lens of hero worship and idealism, but Gilbert does an excellent job of unraveling Conway's complicated motivations, aspirations and frustrations. The two have been friends for years, and it shows in her writing, which is deeply personal — affectionate, yet candid and critical.  In trying to demystify this man — who has already become a legend to many — Gilbert leaves out nothing.  No one this passionate achieves success without having a dark side, and The Last American Man takes the psychoanalytical risks to show why so many people idolize Conway from afar, then practically flee when given the opportunity to know him up close.

Eustace Conway is the owner of Turtle Island, a nature conservatory and ultra-primitive, self-sufficient farm in North Carolina; a sort of non-profit haven for preaching and teaching his message of environmentalism.  Yet despite building and running his own utopia from the ground up, Conway doesn't seem to stay in one place for very long.  He has broken multiple world records for long-distance horse riding and hiked the entire Appalachian Trail with only a small knife, wearing a loin-cloth.  He makes his own clothing out of animal skin.  He's hardcore, to the say the least.  Many would be quick to pin him as a hippie, a bleeding-heart liberal tree-hugger.  But Eustace Conway turns out to be far more complicated than that.  For one, he's shockingly conservative, and a brilliant businessman with a head for self-promotion.  He's a strict authoritarian, and often complains that he would run Turtle Island like a rigid military dictatorship if he could.  A man like Conway couldn't achieve success without being a control-freak.

While reading The Last American Man, it struck me how similar Conway's basic personality traits are to those shown by Mark Zuckerberg (as he was portrayed by Jesse Eisenberg) in The Social Network.  The lives of these men would seem to have little in common on the surface, yet both embody the same relentless drive, the need for absolute control, the perfectionism, the uncanny intellect and talent — and as a result, the tendency to drive away everyone close to them through the sheer intensity of their personality.  These men were born to succeed beyond measure, but might as well wear a plaque around their neck that reads: "... at what cost?"  What makes The Last American Man (and Eustace Conway) so fascinating is not just the adventures Conway has been on, but the way people react to him.  This includes the author, who can't seem to help interjecting her own thoughts and witticisms into the narrative, especially when deconstructing Conway's personal relationships (though to be fair, this might just be her writing style.)  That Gilbert is fascinated and perplexed by Conway even after knowing him so well — indeed, after writing such a thorough book on the man — is telling.  Many of the apprentices that come to Turtle Island to learn about the primitive life seem to look to Conway as a father figure and spiritual guide, and most end up leaving disappointed, jaded and even heartbroken.  Conway has had poor luck with his sexual relationships as well, though he seems to have had no lack of them either.  He is a man who is immediately and obviously compelling, who is described as constantly drawing people into his orbit before suffocating them through the intensity of his personality, the extreme demands he places upon himself and others.

As a book, The Last American Man is not perfect.  Gilbert's intimacy with Conway gives the reader access that few authors would have been able to obtain, or understand, but her tone is occasionally so casual that it's hard to take at face value.  Still, for this style of writing, she could do much worse, and the book has a nice flow and a vibrant, excited energy to match its subject.  The pacing suggests Conway's own trajectory, from capable young idealist to jaded, disappointed businessman.  This, in a way, makes The Last American Man an unintended but insightful commentary on the very nature of idealism, structured around an idealist who did not himself fail, like so many hippies and would-be-Utopians.  Eustace Conway tackled every goal he set up for himself, and he had just as high hopes for America — he truly believed he could save our country by teaching us how live a primitive, knowledgeable, hard-working lifestyle.  He really figured out how to do it, showed us that it works.  But most people are not like Eustace Conway, and the same problems he saw in his youth are looming larger than ever.  Watching this man recognize his own futility through the pages of a mere biography is a tremendously fascinating experience.

Sunday, October 10, 2010

THE CITY AND THE CITY (BY) CHINA MIEVILLE

Published 2009, 312 pages
Characters: B-
Writing: B
Plot: B+
Pacing: A-
Poignancy: A-

Unfortunately, I don't think any book could ever be as badass as the cover of The City and the City suggests, but China Mieville's intricate, atmospheric mystery gives it a pretty good go.  Though the story is framed around a political murder, and never strays too far from other noirish police procedurals in scope of plot, the setting that steers most of Mieville's novel is unlike anything I've ever read.  With the feel of very dry magic realism and gothic dark fantasy, Mieville's style has been described as a cross between Philip K. Dick, Raymond Chandler and Franz Kafka, and I can't really improve upon that.  That, I hope, should be endorsement enough.

The two cities of the title are Beszél and Ul Qoma, conjoined but separate cities somewhere in Eastern Europe, each essentially its own country.  Parallels to real-life separated cities are obvious, like Berlin during the Cold War, but Mieville pushes well past social commentary and into elaborate mind-game.  Beszél and Ul Qoma — though distinct cities with their own unique cultures, languages and histories — share the same, overlapping physical space.  Rather than divided down the middle, each city is spliced together with the other, necessitating a complicated system so that citizens of one town do not "breach" into the other.  The population learns from birth to "unsee" the other city, memorizing which streets exist in which jurisdiction, what shops belong to their nation, and even which cultural signifiers make citizens of the "other" place practically — though not literally — invisible.  It sounds like an outlandish concept, but there is no magic or fantasy involved, only politics.  Mieville plays it so dry that it's easy to accept this scenario as plausible, even if no government could ever realistically make it work.  For obvious reasons, a good deal of the novel is expository — sort of like Inception, which I seem to be referencing a lot lately, in that both are standard thriller plotlines, easy enough to follow on their own but tied to a complicated central structure.  Those anticipating many layers of strangeness and surrealism beyond the basic pitch will be disappointed, but Mieville is able to extract so much from his premise that it really shouldn't matter.

The setting is easily malleable enough to provide its own twists and turns, and therefore a great deal of the narrative is spent establishing the nature of Beszél and Ul Qoma.  Mieville is clever enough to make these the focus of the book — really, its main characters — without ever going off on tangents, or driving his story into the absurd.  Unfortunately, his other characters are never quite as strong, and the structure of the story prevents them from developing much beyond their occupational roles.  This is not to say that the characters are unbelievable or poorly written — they are bland and not particularly deep, but in the way that many real people are bland and not particularly deep, and their actions are always well-scripted and fully convincing.  If The City and the City suffers from one chief weakness, it is that the ending fails to impress after the steady brilliance building up to it.  The conclusion simply lacks the imagination of everything preceding it — many of the red herrings tossed out along the way might have led to a more interesting ending, and the final showdown requires so much exposition as it's unfolding that any tension or suspense is lost.  I had hoped Mieville might have taken the metaphor inherent in his setting a bit further, or add more layers to the many he had already concocted, but the climax is true to the grounded tone the rest of the novel takes.  Mieville has defended this arc as a sort of anti-fantasy — after being given a glimpse of potential, a hint that the book could expand into entirely new worlds, the narrative instead dips down and touches ground again, adhering to the boundaries of reality.  Even if you, like me, are frustrated by this less-exciting turn, The City and the City is still one of the more adventurous, interesting novels to come along in years.

Monday, September 13, 2010

RED HARVEST (BY) DASHIELL HAMMETT

Published 1929, 216 pages
Characters: B-
Writing: B
Plot: B+
Pacing: A-
Poignancy: B-

The protagonist of Red Harvest is a man known only as the Continental Op, a jaded, semi-moral agent for a powerful detective agency in 1920's California.  A ruthless voice of justice who seems to lack any ambitions or passions of his own, Dashiell Hammett's Continental Op would shape future detective characters, an early hardboiled noir anti-hero, just as Hammett's stylish narratives helped to glamorize the nation's prohibition-era problems of gang violence, crooked cops and bought-out politicians.  The details of the Op aren't particularly important, his background left to speculation, and even his motivations often ambiguous.  He's hired to solve a murder in the corrupt mining town of Personville, and when he realizes that no one crime could be solved without cleaning up the whole place, he sets out to shake down the town and set Personville's warring gangs against each other.  Like most noir, the specifics of the plot are often confusing or hard to grasp, and it's generally not worth trying to parse out all the twists and turns. It's style that carries the book.

As a sort of proto-noir, Red Harvest is lean and streamlined despite the intricacies of its plot.  Noir hadn't been around enough at the time for genre conventions to come into effect, so femme fatales in Red Harvest aren't quite what you'd expect, and the Continental Op doesn't spend much time in shadowy bars or dark alleys.  Yet one can see how Hammett became a trendsetter in the genre — his writing style is perfectly suited to taut, no-nonsense crime drama, even if his plotting is a little loose and unnecessarily convoluted.  Scene changes happen fast, like everything else — almost too fast, especially given the number of players involved.  The Op makes wisecracks, sneers at danger; the dames are strong-willed and sassy.  Everyone is corrupt and out to cause trouble, but there's little drama in it, since no-one's motivations are revealed until after the fact.  Hammett's two main leads are reliably interesting characters, easy to follow and successful at carrying the narrative momentum.  But there are dozens of bit players, most of whom aren't alive long enough to be notable.  Some add nothing to the story at all.  Halfway through the book, the Op calls his agency headquarters and asks for backup.  He gets it, in the form of two other detectives sent to work on the same case — something that's certainly not common in noir, so often built around a lone-wolf anti-hero.  But in the end these two other characters are no more than two new names to keep track of, and they vanish from the story off and on, adding nothing but a slight touch of realism and scale.  Which is nice, but there's already a lot to keep track of in Red Harvest, and the Op's unrealistic detective abilities don't make things any easier.  Solutions to crimes aren't solved so much as announced, and then quickly passed over.  The murder that opens the novel could have easily sustained most of the plot, but it ends up as only a minor step along the way.  The Op often just knows — who killed who, and why — but the reader hasn't a chance of keeping up with his revelations until he dishes them out.  It's a little disorienting, and makes each new reveal seem weightless and insignificant.  Still, there's no doubt that the book's pacing is exhilarating, and the action is always fun, the dialogue always snappy.  Hammett was a genuinely skilled writer.  The narrative shares the easy, pushy confidence of its protagonist, so you won't find a dull page here.  I expected Red Harvest to serve mostly as an interesting glimpse into history, a genre retrospective, but its punch still feels fresh.  There's no point in trying to keep up — this is a roller coaster ride, a fun one, but there's no chance of straying off the tracks or even guessing where they're headed.

Thursday, August 19, 2010

INTERPRETER OF MALADIES (BY) JHUMPA LAHIRI

Published 1999, 198 Pages
Characters: A
Writing: A-
Plot(s): B
Pacing: B+
Poignancy: B+

In the title story of Jhumpa Lahiri's short story collection, Interpreter of Maladies, an Indian tour guide guides an American-Indian couple around the historical sites of their native land, a country they associate with but have never visited before.  He begins to take an interest in the wife of the group, projecting his own marital problems onto this stranger's relationship.  Yet as a guide, he can do no more than observe from behind a social wall and go home with no real revelations except some faint disappointment.  In a way — and likely for good reason, as it is the title piece — this short story works as an abstract for the collection as a whole, and maybe even this whole subgenre of literary fiction.  Lahiri writes beautifully crafted, endearing character pieces that tug at a few melancholy emotional strings before fading away, with no clear lessons learned.  Like the interpreter in question, Lahiri plays the role of a listener as well as narrator, and refrains from explicitly stating her judgements. 

Lahiri is far from alone in realizing that subtlety leads to a more organic relationship between reader and character.  But unlike the many, many who attempt this style — the ending so ambiguous you might not even notice it's over, the depressed, doomed protagonists — Lahiri's prose is exceptionally strong and her characters more vivid than average.  There's a healthy amount of variety and creativity in the plots of these shorts, putting her ahead of peers like Lorrie Moore, as far as I'm concerned.  There are, of course, the multiple stories about doomed marriages and mid-life romantic failures, but Lahiri attempts a few more experimental pieces, and is much better than most at letting her characters stand out through their own personalities, rather than seeming mere avatars of the author.  Almost every piece is based around Indian culture in some way, but never to the extent that it becomes the primary driving force of the story.

If I have any criticism of Lahiri's style, it's that she is perhaps a little too passive in too many stories.  Few writers are as skilled at pulling themselves back as a narrator and letting each story reach its end with no real conclusion or catharsis, but even so, Lahari doesn't quite escape the trap of this type of story.  Though this is a short collection, under 200 pages with just nine stories, only a few of them left any real impression on me.  Lahiri falters in most of the pieces set in India, where she attempts to mix a more traditional-sounding narration with quirky literary character pieces.  Other stories simply feel too small.  With such vivid characters featured in the best stories here, those in between feel more arbitrary in comparison, and lacked 'punch' in some important way.  Still, this isn't so much a criticism as a result, and in any short story collection, a reader is going to focus most on the stories they connect to.  I wasn't able to fully connect with everything here, but this isn't really Lahiri's fault.  Interpreter of Maladies deserves a solid recommendation as a collection full of natural characters and sophisticated literary craftsmanship.

Sunday, July 18, 2010

1776 (BY) DAVID MCCULLOUGH

Published 1996 , 294 Pages
Characters: n/a
Writing: A-
Plot: n/a
Pacing: A
Poignancy: A

If you aren't familiar with David McCullough, one thing is important to know before reading one of his pop-history works: McCullough isn't writing for academics, history buffs or researchers.  A book like 1776 is the written equivalent of a History Channel special.  Personally, I don't see anything wrong with that.  If you want an intense study of the Revolutionary War, certainly look elsewhere.  If you just want to read a book — an entertaining book, even — and finish it knowing a bit more about history, than 1776 is just right for you.  In fact, it's perfect.

Admittedly, I'm pretty ignorant of most historical periods past the fall of Rome.  The last time I studied anything related to the American Revolution was exactly a decade ago.  My judgment of 1776 is based purely on its merits as a book, not as a historical analysis — but since it was given to me by a Revolutionary War reenactor and Thomas Jefferson impersonator, and has received fairly universal praise for its Pulitzer Prize winning author, I'm going to assume that its accuracy is beyond me to question.  This is a highly focused examination of one year in America's history that rarely strays from the side of General Washington, his generals and the British men facing him in battle.  Don't even expect to learn how the American Revolution ended, because 1776 — as its title implies — cuts off after the pivotal battles of Trenton and Princeton, long before the end of the war.  The Declaration of Independence is barely mentioned, the Continental Congress operates in the background, and the reasons for the war's beginning are only alluded to.  Is it somewhat odd for a non-fiction work to only barely scratch the surface of its subject?  Certainly it's a bold move, but the rewards are great.  I do wish that McCullough had continued all the way to the Siege of Yorktown and the end of the war, but only because he knows how to tell this story so well.

After all, there's a reason for the surge of pop history books becoming bestsellers in the last decade: most people don't want to bury themselves in a long, unrewarding academic tome.  Few people can absorb such large volumes of information, and histories are easily bogged down by the dozen branches their subject matter takes.  If the experience of reading such a book isn't rewarding, there's even less chance of remembering the history you wanted to study in the first place.  In this respect, 1776 succeeds magnificently: it reads like a novel, and a good one.  Few books this year have compelled me to turn the page as this one has; a doubly remarkable achievement considering I already knew the ending.  The suffering and setbacks faced by the American soldiers is real and fully-explored; McCullough injects suspense and tension into the events simply by layering his sources for maximum effect.  There were times when I thought to myself:  "Wow. I really want to know what happens.  And I'm reading this on Independence Day, so..." 

That's about the best praise I could think of for a book like this, but 1776 isn't soft on the historical details either.  McCullough offers little commentary of his own, though his assessments of the "character's'" thoughts, strategies and worries is always timely, useful and reasonable.  By sticking close to his source material, McCullough keeps the information grounded and even manages to create some historical atmosphere.  Indeed, the ultimate reason that 1776 is so readable both as a book and a history is McCullough's prose, which is clear, strong and enjoyable.  This is a man with a sure command over the English language, and he uses it to his full advantage, creating a historical narrative that earned its place at the top of best-seller lists.

Monday, July 12, 2010

THE MAGICIANS (BY) LEV GROSSMAN

Published 2009, 402 Pages
Characters: B
Writing: A-
Plot: B+
Pacing: B+
Poignancy: A

A lot of reviewers have branded Lev Grossman's novel The Magicians as "Harry Potter for adults."  It's an obvious selling point, I guess, and I can see how a lot of people would get distracted by the novel's highly referential first half and conclude that that's all this is.  A few hundred pages of The Magicians does indeed take place at a secret magical school hidden from normal society, and Grossman goes beyond just glancing similarities — the characters themselves reference Harry Potter on multiple occasions so we don't have to, as well as Tolkien and probably a dozen others.  Which is the point: this is meta-fantasy, a novel about the sort of people who read fantasy novels rather than the adventure itself.  After all, what is fantasy?  The general structure, whether taking place at a magical school or in a far-away mystical land, is that a troubled youth is whisked away to discover how special he is, and finds his place in his world by mastering the art of magic. The idea is that, wherever the character goes, he or she is entering, literally, a fantasy.   

The Magicians takes a fairly obvious but nonetheless clever step back from all this, acknowledging that most of us grew up wishing for these very fantasies to take us away.  The novel's protagonist, Quentin Coldwater, grew up reading a famous fantasy series called Fillory and Further, novels which are very obviously meant to fill in for The Chronicles of Narnia (though they work as general archetypes as well, if you've never read Lewis' series).  The Fillory series mirrors The Chronicles of Narnia in nearly every single way, and goes far beyond mere background reference — without giving too much of the plot away, let's just say it's an extremely integral part of the story.  So it's surprising to me that The Magicians is compared to the Harry Potter series so often, when in many ways it serves as a direct rebuttal — almost a re-writing of — The Chronicles of Narnia. 

As you can probably tell, Grossman is trying to pull off a lot of tricks for one mostly-self-contained novel.  While he never reaches quite the same level as the novels he's referencing, The Magicians is easily one of the most interesting, daring novels I've read in some time, and I found it to be incredibly addicting: even with its substantial 400 pages, I finished the entire novel in four days.  It's definitely a page-turner, and a smart one, which I attribute mostly to its unpredictable and fast-moving plot.  In retrospect, I have to admit that the plot isn't half of what it could have been, and Grossman plays his cards safer than I was imagining.  Yet as I was reading, I truly had no idea what to expect — it's one of those novels that maintains a sense that nearly anything could happen within a chapter or two (even if it doesn't, really).  Possibly this is all just a result of the brevity with which Grossman deals out his plot points.  The Magicians would have earned its Harry Potter comparisons if the characters had stayed in school for longer, yet these five years of the character's lives only take up the first half of the book.  Brakebills College for Magic isn't central to the plot the way that Hogwarts is — it's mostly there to be there, to establish the world that the characters inhabit.  Even in the pivotal final third of the book, few plot elements are given much attention, despite most of the sets being interesting enough to carry a novel of their own.  Though it would have been rather crass of Grossman to have given this the series treatment, The Magicians could have been at least twice as long with few ill effects.  At times, it does feel as if there are chapters missing, or scenes that perhaps got cut down.  While the brisk speed at which the narrative moves might patch over the pacing problems Grossman might have faced in a longer novel, some could view this is a pacing problem on its own: too much speed and too little substance.  But to be fair, this only really bothered me in the later half, when the plot suddenly opens up and has the potential to go in any number of crazy directions, only to settle for what was probably the safest possible route.

All of this, I suspect, was done in order to make sure that Grossman's thesis wasn't lost amongst all the fantasy tropes he's exploiting.  Grossman wasn't really writing a fantasy, after all: he was writing about the sort of people who get sucked into fantasy novels, and why such an obsession can be as dangerous as it is tempting.   Though Quentin is sometimes unlikeable and occasionally downright annoying, he's fairly realistic for a main character.  The side characters are somewhat weaker, and though Grossman is a good enough writer to provide each with an authentic voice, most of the characters never develop or change, and a few are ultimately irrelevant.  But it's the lessons that these characters learn that ultimately resounds, and the reason I can so easily forgive the novel for its disappointments. It isn't easy to write a novel spilling over with genre-tropes and cliches and yet have it seem original and fresh, but that's just what Grossman's done.  So it isn't the plot that matters in the end, or even the nature of the fantasy itself, but the very fact that we're being brought back to it, seeing what we've seen before in an entirely new light.

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

NEVER LET ME GO (BY) KAZUO ISHIGURO

Published 2006, 304 Pages
Characters: B-
Writing: B+
Plot: B
Pacing: B+
Poignancy: B+

Set in an ever-so-slightly-alternate universe England over a period roughly analogous to the end of the last century, Never Let Me Go is a retrospective first-person tale narrated by a 'carer' named Kathy.  Kathy lives in a world that seems hostile to her very existence, but this is not quite dystopian lit.  It's a world where science has led us in new directions, but it's not quite sci-fi.  It's hard to gauge just what Never Let Me Go is, exactly, and Ishiguro wisely keeps his cards close to his chest.  This short novel has no action, few characters and only a couple barely noticeable scene changes, yet unravels with such precision and deft timing that it should be a quick, engaging read for almost anyone.

Though this is not a mystery novel, either, Ishiguro creates an artificial one as his main hook — we know from page one that Kathy does something strange and possibly dangerous for a living, but we're never told directly what.  There's a general feeling of inevitability and fear that plays out beautifully in the narration as the smallest of details clue us into the fact that her world is different from ours — and after all, when are alternate universes ever not malicious places? We're told of Hailsham, a special private school in the countryside where Kathy grew up and was prepared by secretive teachers to do... something. The characters, when children, are as oblivious to their purpose as We The Reader are, but as we skip around in time and they age, they seem to absorb an understanding of their purpose through rumors and whispers, while we do not.  Ishiguro loves foreshadowing — a little too much, perhaps, though his writing is solid in every other area — and Kathy is a bumbling, hesitant narrator, so it's clear that the children are at this special school for some strange and sinister purpose.  But what?  To become wizards? It's an entirely artificial mystery, especially when Kathy and her friends are teenagers free to explore the outside world, but it doesn't quite detract from the story.  Without it, the slow pacing would become a distraction, but as it is, the story slips by as quickly (and blurrily, and often confusingly) as a memory.  Unlike certain writers and producers of Lost, Ishiguro doesn't use his narrative mystery to force artificial tension or misdirection — it's simply there, lingering in the background, with the understanding that we're to pay attention to the character's interactions rather than try to unravel any secrets a few pages early.

Never Let Me Go is wonderfully paced and nearly-always engaging, but this brevity could be taken as a weakness as well.  I often wished for more depth, in nearly every area of the story.  The school, Hailsham, is established as an enormous emotional investment for Kathy, yet I never felt it come to life.  Most of her classmates — including Kathy's friend Ruth, one of the most important characters in the novel — are adequately characterized, but little more.  Even the novel's main foil, Kathy's friend and sometimes love-interest Tommy, isn't given enough time to bond with Kathy, which severely diminished the ultimate payoff.  Their relationship is convincingly sketched out, earnest and natural, yet I felt it never really went beyond the page — it never became emotional to me, and maybe not even to the characters themselves, who remain strangely distant and guarded throughout.  For all the little details that Ishiguro slips in to "show" rather than "tell," their relationship simply isn't there for long enough to make the reader feel as much as they could.

Ultimately, Never Let Me Go is still incredibly readable and largely satisfying.  It is a novel that lacks any show-stopping faults, but it isn't a heavy-hitter either.  I'd recommend it, but I wouldn't rave about it.  Considering how poorly constructed the majority of novels are, when you really analyze them, Ishiguro should be commended for this solid and thought-provoking genre-bender.

Monday, May 3, 2010

TALES (BY) H.P. LOVECRAFT

Published 2005, 807 pages
Characters: C-
Writing: B-
Plot/Pacing: B-
Poignancy: A

Most people have heard of H.P. Lovecraft, or at least something he created, but many that I talk to don't seem to realize it.  Mostly unknown during his lifetime, with no singular novel or story to stand as his masterpiece, Lovecraft's immense catalog of short fiction was left to slowly seep into the public consciousness, creating the sort of cult phenomenon that people casually reference without fully understanding.  A pioneer of macabre fantasy, Lovecraft clearly took after one of his idols, Edgar Alan Poe, and the two are together responsible for nearly every trope and cliche of modern fantasy horror.  Lovecraft introduced the world to Cthulhu, the Necronomicon, and a mythology of cosmic terror that drew from the forward-thinking pulp fiction of the day. For a reader only now discovering his writing, it's hard to know where to start, but a bit of research led me to Tales, The Library of America anthology of his most notable works. Even at 800 pages, it still excludes a great deal of Lovecraft's stories, but by all accounts includes all the vital ones.

Undoubtedly the best time to read Lovecraft is when you are a 15 year old boy.  That's not to say his work is immature, or won't appeal to anyone else, but there is a reason why fantasy is extremely popular in that demographic, and Lovecraft really hones in on that sense of unbridled imagination and limitless fantastic potential.  Possibly to the point of fault — his stories, no matter their length, pretty much all follow the same formula. Characters are secondary to Lovecraft's vision of vast, secret planes of reality and lurking ancient terrors, and his protagonists are unfailingly upper-middle class white males of an inquisitive yet reserved nature.  They are generally from an intellectual background, so as to be appropriately skeptical, and upon discovering a hint of intrigue, they investigate and uncover, expressing strained disbelief, shock, fear, and ultimately revealing some terrible, dangerous secret that threatens their very sanity.  In many of the stories, nothing actually happens to the protagonist himself — he merely uncovers some earlier events, or discovers a mystery so terrifying that he must flee it at once.  Lovecraft didn't write tepidly, and it's both the reason for his success and the major flaw of his stories.  Everything that happens is so earth-shattering that grown men regularly faint with terror, and these revelations are usually described with every colorful, antiquated adjective Lovecraft could get his hands on.  By the end of the collection, you'll wonder if he was getting paid by the number of times he used the word "eldritch".  It was clearly not the strength of his prose that made Lovecraft a horror-fiction icon, but his imagination.

With that said, I very much enjoyed this collection, despite Lovecraft's flaws.  It's the sort of fiction that functions best in hindsight, in the reader's own imagination, where it was meant to exist.  Lovecraft was ahead of his time in the scope of his stories, yet somewhat limited by his own technical abilities and publication niche — I can only imagine the sort of tale he would have been forced to concoct if he'd been contracted to write a full-length novel.  His world is a grim, hopeless place, where mere humans are helpless against the ancient gods that sometimes awake to harass them, and the overwhelming sense of entropy and nihilism in his stories is one of the reasons Lovecraft endures so well, and remains unique.  His protagonists are helpless to confront the things they face, often questioning their own sanity as a result.  Unlike most fantasy authors, Lovecraft never suggested that any man would be able to stand in the face of true evil and survive.  It is the primary reason for there being so little action in any of Lovecraft's stories, and the reason his expositional narratives ultimately work.  In most of these tales, the protagonist is forced to flee, and human bravery rarely has any consequence.  When the world of humans survives for another day, it is not by heroics or cunning but sheer luck.  Lovecraft made it explicitly clear that he expected our species to be extinct within a short time, that we were but one of many intelligent civilizations that might inhabit the earth.  Such a dismal view of humanity is still quite rare, even in horror fiction.

When his stories are taken together, it's clear that Lovecraft often flailed about, finding horror in far too many things to be taken entirely seriously.  Every run-down house or distant hill, every gust of cool air or strange smell, every cave and crevasse and distant mountain range might conceal some terrible secret.  Foreigners are all "swarthy" racial stereotypes linked to a sinister cult — The Horror at Red Hook is interesting if only because it so clearly links the "otherness" Lovecraft feared from supernatural horrors to the "otherness" born of racial tensions in 1920's New York City, revealing both as essentially the same psychological mechanism, the fear of the unknown. With such broad material, Lovecraft often comes across as just a paranoid, racist old man.  Nonetheless, there was an astoundingly rich vision behind these tales, a mind that was imaginative enough to write about entities so vast that no human could fully comprehend their existence, and yet realist enough to see that such things were contrary to our own existence, that even glimpsing such unnatural beings only meant that our end was near, like an ant finally comprehending the great shadow above it moments before it is crushed.

Tuesday, October 13, 2009

DARWINIA (BY) ROBERT CHARLES WILSON

Published 1998, 320 pages
Characters: B
Writing: B-
Plot: A / Pacing: D-
Poignancy: C+

It's a rare occasion that a book so full of Really Cool Ideas capsizes due to an immensely obvious and easily-avoided flaw. Most authors understand basic tenets of pacing and plot development, or they're just not very good writers to begin with. I can't recall any book quite like Darwinia, a book otherwise really really good, but suffering from a pacing-choice so bizarre that literally every single review on Amazon mentions it with the caveat: "good except for..."

The basic back-cover gist of Darwinia is that in 1912, all of Europe and the UK are suddenly replaced by a bizarro-land that seems to have evolved along a different timeline than our own. All former inhabitants of the effected areas vanish along with every remnant of old Europe. The continent becomes, in effect, a vast unexplored wilderness. It's an interesting enough premise on its own to sustain an entire narrative, but the author takes the story in a rapidly-escalating sci-fi direction rather than dwell on a potential alternate-history / steampunk spin. Wilson essentially promises the reader from the beginning that all mysteries will be explained scientifically, but it's still jarring when the story totally shifts direction in the second half. Darwinia is an incredibly difficult book to review without giving away major plot points and background, because the book's flaws as well as its brilliance are inseparable from its complicated plot. Therefore, forgive my vagueness.

Essentially, the problem is similar to this. Imagine halfway through The Sixth Sense a titlecard came up that said "INTERLUDE" and M. Night walked up in front of a frozen-screen of the movie. "Okay, here's the deal," M. Night says. "Bruce Willis, in this movie, is a ghost. He's been dead since the beginning. You remember that scene? Yeah, he died. So he can't really die again in the rest of the movie or anything. I wouldn't even worry about it. He's a ghost. Okay."

It's more complicated than that, of course, but that horrifically puzzling storytelling choice would have been as inexplicable as what the author attempts to do here. There is literally a chapter called "Interlude" not even a third of the way through the book, and it gives away the whole gambit all in one nonsensical swoop. The exposition has no connection to the chapters and events surrounding it. The characters in the book are not aware of it. It destroys the drama and danger that follow after. And at first you think, "Well, this sudden sci-fi twist probably couldn't be comprehended by primitive 1920-era characters with no means of understanding such concepts. I guess the author just needed a way to reveal what he couldn't reveal through natural exposition." But no. A hundred pages later, the main character finds out the exact same information, in-story. It's revealed clearly and effectively. There is then another interlude chapter, reiterating the same information. Not only is that first interlude give-away unnecessary, drama-destroying and jarring, but it's fucking redundant! Everything would have worked absolutely fine if he hadn't dropped his ace on the table before the betting even got good.

The further into Darwinia you progress, the more frustrating this really becomes. For one, the Heart of Darknessesque expedition that makes up the first half of the book is quite interesting, even though Wilson is inconsistent with his New World and the dangers it presents. A lot of opportunities for suspense and mystery are ignored or ruined. If the end-game were still a mystery to the reader, as it is to the characters, a lot of the surrealist horror and unexplained happenings would have far more weight. Instead, the world around them is all-but forgotten, becoming trivial and tame.

When Wilson finally drops that second, in-story reveal (which is no longer satisfying for the reader), the story takes the u-turn hinted at earlier and finds its footing once more. The last portion of the book is tightly plotted and intricate in back-story, all of which works surprisingly well given its out-thereness. Wilson truly has some wonderful ideas, even if other variations of the same concept have been done before. This book could easily have been a trilogy, far more epic and detailed than the version Wilson gave us. As it is, the material is given barely-enough attention—making that goddam reveal all the more perplexing. It makes me hope for an alternate Earth in which all of this book (as well as the UK) are replaced with a bizarro version in which Wilson has learned how to pace a novel.

Tuesday, May 6, 2008

LIES MY TEACHER TOLD ME (BY) JAMES LOEWEN

I could not ignore a book with such an accusative title as it lay before me at the bookstore. A book of revisionist history could go either way, and while I'm not sure if I got what I was expecting, or even what the cover promised, I'm glad for its enticing siren-song. Now released again in hardcover for one of its umpteenth reprints, this revised version of the 1995 original is a national best-seller and certainly much more than a gimmick; from what I can tell, it's been extremely influential to its field. This is a book that should be read, even if said title is a bit misleading. A more accurate title would be "The Unspoken History of Racism in America; Or, White Guilt is a Pretty Goddam Complicated Issue." Loewen's criticism is actually mostly reserved for the history textbooks and the highly dubious publishing methods and ghost-writers that create them—not, in fact, the teachers who teach them, most of whom are themselves ignorant of history, as they are often simply gym coaches and other plug-in history amateurs attempting to hold their own in the most unpopular of high school classes.

Towards the end of the book, Loewen goes through the process of textbook creation. He finds that the authors on the cover—often noted historians or important college professors—almost always had nothing to do with the actual writing process. Either their names were rented or bought for the illusion of credibility, or they wrote some early edition back in the 50's. In many cases, the "authors" have no ideas what the books actually say, and when Loewen introduced them to certain sections that they allegedly wrote, they were shocked and horrified. The true authors are invisible, unaccountable, and often themselves ignorant of history, simply copying, pasting and rewriting from one another to create a bland blend of "facts" that grow more muddled and PC over the years. The idea, which the author argues convincingly, is not that there is some conspiracy of rich white men dictating what patriotic factoids students are allowed to be taught (which he defensively suggests is a ridiculous and nonsensical idea), but simply a result of the textbook adoption process. School boards want books that will not receive complaints, that will inspire patriotism and make students feel good about their heritage. As anyone who reads the newspaper and takes note of frivolous lawsuits knows, parents these days are an uppity lot. So it's fairly understandable, but as statistics and the students themselves show, this bland white-washing of history, erasing our country's tumultuous and often cringe-inducing heritage creates a boring, irrelevant piece of propaganda that students instantly reject, either out of boredom, an inability to relate or a subconscious knowledge that what they're being fed is more synthetic and structured than a McDonalds hamburger.

The main bulk of the book is therefore a run-down of the sort of compelling historic narrative that the author argues is missing from our texts. If you have to wonder whether or not his point is valid, simply take the success of the book's contents—it certainly makes for an engrossing, engaging read, and I covered it's 400-odd pages in three or four days. That in itself should make the case for the books validity, but naturally it's more complicated than that. As with the title, the book's aim is somewhat ambiguous, because it is neither a straight-forward critique of the textbooks themselves, nor is it "filling in the blanks" by acting as a stand-alone history textbook. It falls somewhere in between, with Loewen covering scattered chunks of America's history—only in areas he feels are relevant, however, as his objective is not to write an authoritative, complete history volume, but the idea of what one might be. He presents the sort of information the textbooks leave out, while at the same time quoting and critiquing the 20-or-so textbooks he has selected for reference. Therefore, because it's not a book of straight-up "missing information", it is written with a strong voice and quite a bit of opinion. His own take on history glares through, at times when it is not really needed, and not necessarily helpful. While there are few areas where I outright disagreed with him, he too often takes the opportunity to inject his authorial flavor into an argument that would have been just as well presented by simply dropping the facts and showing how the textbooks are overtly manipulative.

Loewen is clearly distraught with the state of things, and despite his obvious opinions, he manages to avoid damning any one group of people. While he clearly leans to the left politically, his criticism usually only emerges where warranted—against any ethnic, political or spiritual faction. And while his conclusion seems to be that almost all textbooks are worthless, I don't think he even means to suggest that every issue or forgotten fact he mentions should be included in them. For example, the Pilim's were so hapless when it came to survival, so ignorant of how to living off the land, that at one point they took to digging up the corpses of Indians and eating them. The Indians, coincidentally, were all dead from the White Man's plague that swept through earlier. Middle-schoolers do not need to read about necrocannibalism. However, it is the tone that Loewen rages against, the absurd portrayal of the Native Americas as ignorant savages who "had never seen such a feast as the Pilgrims presented at that First Thanksgiving." As Americans, we need to understand that God did not simply drop us on this continent free of charge because a couple guys got together and prayed really hard. This country was not formed without struggle and injustice. America represents freedom to many, but even our freedoms have not always been on the side of right. Americans, and our politicians, can be both wrong and malicious.

Both the Civil War and the Alamo were conflicts we fought bitterly and many died for, to maintain freedom—in both cases, we fought and died to maintain the right to own slaves. Few have any idea that the Alamo was fought for this reason—its participants are American heroes, after all. Before Columbus landed, there were 100 million human beings living in the Americas. At the same time, the population of Europe was 70 million. Hundreds of millions died over the next five hundred years, many of them of disease, and in a very short amount of time. Granted, the Europeans could not have known what they were unleashing, but nonetheless they praised God for doing it for them. In many cases, if disease didn't suffice, they simply enslaved the native population—the Spanish were particularly brutal in this regard. We celebrate Columbus, oddly. He has his own holiday. And as most know by now, he was not even the first to discover the Americas, he was essentially the last.

Loewen excels at bridging connections from seemingly unrelated historical coincidences. For example, the Native Americans of the north were disease-free, for reasons I won't get into here. When Lief Erikson and other Scandinavians reached North America hundreds of years before Columbus, they did so out of their own northern countries, through Iceland and Greenland, passing through climates that germs did not tolerate, and essentially sterilizing themselves. They did not bring the plagues that later Europeans did, and therefore their presence did not result in a holocaust of early biological warfare. Given that the Vikings were essentially no more technologically advanced than the Native Americans they encountered, it's no wonder their colonization didn't take off. (To be fair, I suppose it's possible they just didn't pray as hard as Columbus did). I find this unfortunate, as we could today be speaking Norse instead, and celebrating International Viking Day and heading home to see our parents and exchange gifts for Plunderandpillage Week. Connections and historical debates like this highlight the fact that history is not simply a collection of known facts, but a dynamic, tumultuous subject that is neutral of moral and message, and all the more interesting for it. Students, Loewen demonstrates, would be more engaged by such a version of history, compelled to do their own research and ask questions, rather than simply memorizing dozens of meaningless and inconsequential factoids.

In conclusion: While certainly capable as a transport vessel, the yacht strives too hard to add the little touches typically representative of a pleasure-craft, and therefore handles a bit clumsily. In able hands it can hardly be faulted for its seaworthy-ness, but if left unattended the craft drifts slightly to port. The hull is of fine construction, though with some cosmetic oddities, and somewhat inefficiently streamlined. Overall a worthy purchase if one wishes for an enduring, steady ship, but not one to take out racing. Probably will not get you laid.

Related Posts-